| |
This study was undertaken
in patients with productive and non productive types of chronic
cough. The response to treatment with Diakof, a sugar free polyherbal
formulation was evaluated for its effect in diabetic patients. These
patients did not have symptoms suggesting variable airflow obstruction,
and had normal spirometric values and peak expiratory flow variability,
no airway hyper responsiveness or sputum eosinophilia (> 3%).
Fifty-one patients with chronic cough were identified among 200
referrals. The patients were suffering from various upper and lower
respiratory tract infections, but a majority of them had bronchitis.
The patients were dispensed Diakof syrup at a dose of 2 teaspoonsful
three to 4 times a day for 2- 3 weeks. The diabetic patients began
to respond from the first week. 43% were totally relieved, 25.49%
had mild symptoms and 17.64% had moderate symptoms, while cough
persisted in 13.72%. After 15 days treatment, 76.47% of the patients
were completely relieved, while3.92% of the patients had moderate
symptoms and 13.72% had mild symptoms. In 3 patients who reported
only marginal relief, adjuvant therapy had to be given for their
ailments. In 8 of the patients who had a follow-up sputum analysis,
the eosinophil count decreased significantly from 16.8% to 1.6%.
Thus, Diakof can be a useful drug in treating symptoms of cough
in diabetic patients.
Chronic cough is a
common symptom in clinical practice, which if not treated may become
refractory in nature. Some researchers have identified asthma, rhinitis,
and gastroesophageal reflux (GER) as the most common causes of chronic
cough1-4. Frequently, patients have more than one of these conditions.
The underlying mechanisms of cough in these conditions are not defined.
Hyperresponsiveness
of the upper airway (UAHR) resulting from inflammatory mediator
release could be a common mechanism of cough in these patients5,6.
The upper airway has abundant cough receptors, and stimulation of
these receptors leads to cough, reflex laryngeal closure and intermittent
upper airway obstruction. The release of inflammatory mediators7
could cause hypersensitivity of the upper airway to histamine, which
is present in patients with symptoms resembling asthma (including
cough), ACE inhibitor cough8 and in rhinitis. Inflammation is a
feature of the most common conditions which are associated with
chronic cough. In asthma and rhinitis, there is mucosal inflammation
with eosinophils and mast cells9-11. Proximal reflux of acid in
GER results in posterior laryngitis12 and hypersensitivity of the
cough reflex13. In addition, ACE inhibition, which is also associated
with chronic cough, and UAHR could enhance the tussive effects of
tachykinins, which are normally inactivated by ACE in lung tissue14.
The presence of inflammatory mediators in the upper airway could
enhance the sensitivity of afferent nerves. Thus, it is hypothesised
that airway inflammation induced by these diseases would cause hyper-responsiveness
of the upper airway to histamine provocation and that this would
be the unifying mechanism that explains the occurrence of chronic
cough in asthma, rhinitis, GER and ACE inhibitor therapy.
The above symptoms
can be controlled with different conventional formulations. However,
in diabetic patients it has limitations because most of the available
cough syrups contain sugar. Therefore a study with Diakof Linctus,
a non-sugar formulation was conducted.
Patients with chronic cough lasting
for more than 3 weeks were identified from new patient referrals
made by primary care physicians in both rural and urban areas. The
patients were aged between 28 and 76 years. The patients with chronic
cough had no clinical or radiologic evidence of significant lung
disease at the time of referral.
Thirty adult male and
20 female diabetic patients referred to the respiratory outpatient
clinics with chronic cough as the predominant symptom gave informed
consent to be enrolled in the study. All the patients had cough
for more than 4 weeks and a normal chest X-ray prior to inclusion
in the study.
The subjects had a
full history taken and a physical examination was performed. The
history was recorded on a standardized questionnaire, and previous
medical problems, medications, smoking history, amount of sputum
and hemoptysis were recorded. The primary diagnosis was rhinitis
in 7, asthma in 9, post-viral-infection status in 5, bronchitis
in 21, gastroesophageal reflux in 3, COPD in 1, bronchiectasis in
2 and ACE inhibitor-induced cough in 3. The cause of chronic cough
remained unexplained in 5 patients (Table 1). Subjects rated the
frequency, severity, and symptoms suppression related to cough using
4-point scale, where 0 corresponded to no symptoms, 1 to mild symptoms,
2 to moderate symptoms, and 3 to maximum symptom intensity. Complications
of chronic cough, including rib fracture, syncope, headache, sleep
disturbance, urinary incontinence and social disruption more recoded.
Symptoms of intercurrent disease such as post-nasal drip, GER, and
asthma were reported on the 7-point scale. A standard self-administered
psychiatric symptom questionnaire (SCL-90R) was also administered.
Sputum volume and the size and number of plugs were recorded. Clinical
diagnoses were made according to the following criteria: rhinitis
was considered to be present when there was a history of current
(past week) symptoms of post-nasal drip, nasal stuffiness, or sneezing
rated 4/7 on the 7 point scale; asthma was diagnosed when there
was a history of cough and current variable airflow obstruction
clinically, GE reflux was diagnozed when symptoms of indigestion
and regurgitation of fluids and food were present at a severity
of 4 on a scale of 1 to 7, sinusitis was diagnozed by a history
of facial pain and a response to antibiotics. Subjects using ACE
inhibitors, either recurrently or previously at the time of coughing
were considered to have ACE inhibitor cough.
|
Table 1: Causes
of Chronic Cough (n=51)
|
| Disease |
No.
of patients
|
Percentage
(%)
|
| Rhinitis |
7
|
13.71
|
| Asthma |
9
|
17.64
|
| Post
viral |
5
|
9.80
|
| Bronchitis |
21
|
41.17
|
| Gastro
esophageal reflux |
3
|
5.88
|
| COPD |
1
|
1.98
|
| Bronchiectasis |
2
|
3.92
|
| ACE
inhibitor - induced cough |
1
|
5.88
|
| Unexplained |
5
|
9.80
|
The cough was present
for an average of 4-6 weeks. The majority of the patients had been
on unsuccessful trials of medications, with 16 having received inhaled
corticosteroids, 10 antibiotics, 6 inhaled b2 agonists, 7 histamine-type
2 receptor antagonists, 8 antacids, 6 oral corticosteroids, 4 inhaled
cromoglycate, 2 nasal decongestants, 2 nasal corticosteroids, and
1 omeprazole. Most (38/51) patients had experienced several cough
related complications. These included sleep disturbance (17/51),
social disruption (16/51), urinary incontinence (5/51), presyscope
(6/51), headache (15/51), syncope (2/51), back and chest pains (28/51),
exhaution (10/51) and hoarseness of voice (8/51) (Table 2). These
patients were asked to get their fasting and postprandial blood
sugar levels checked till the end of the study period. They were
also requested not to stop antidiabetic treatment for any reason.
|
Table 2: Psychological
symptoms in the patients (n=51)
|
| Symptom |
No.
of patients
|
Percentage
(%)
|
| Sleep
disturbances |
17
|
33.33
|
| Social
disturbances |
16
|
31.17
|
| Urinary
incontinence |
5
|
9.80
|
| Presyscope |
6
|
11.76
|
| Headache |
15
|
29.41
|
| Syncope |
2
|
3.92
|
| Back
and chest pain |
28
|
54.90
|
| Exhaution |
10
|
19.60
|
| Hoarseness |
8
|
25.80
|
The results showed
that most of the patients responded well to the cough syrup. The
patients who came for follow-up after a week reported that they
had felt a soothing effect over the inflamed upper respiratory tract.
Out of the 51 patients who came for follow up, 22 were totally relieved
of the cough symptoms. However, they were advised to continue the
medication for another 8 days. Thirteen patients had mild symptoms,
9 patients reported moderate symptoms and the symptoms of cough
persisted in 7 patients. These patients were advised salt water
gargle in addition to consumption of the cough syrup. After 15 days,
39 patients reported complete relief from chronic cough and were
psychologically free from any symptoms. Seven patients had minimal
cough occurring occasionally and continued the treatment till the
symptoms disappeared totally. Two had moderate symptoms and 3 patients
out of the 51 felt that the symptoms were still present and requested
for additional medication (Table 3). They were prescribed additional
oral antihistamine tablets along with Diakof syrup.
| Table
3: Presence of cough symptoms before and after treatment with
Diakof Linctus in diabetic patients |
| Duration |
Symptom |
No.
of patients
|
Percentage
(%)
|
| Before
treatment |
Severe |
36
|
70.58
|
| Moderate |
11
|
21.56
|
| Mild |
4
|
7.84
|
| Nil |
-
|
-
|
| After
7 days |
Severe |
7
|
13.72
|
| Moderate |
9
|
17.64
|
| Mild |
13
|
25.49
|
| Nil |
22
|
43.13
|
| After
15 days |
Severe |
3
|
5.88
|
| Moderate |
2
|
3.92
|
| Mild |
7
|
13.72
|
| Nil |
39
|
76.47
|
The cause or causes
for chronic cough in most patients, confirming the diagnostic value
of the anatomic-diagnostic approach was successful identified15.
The treatment success rate of 90.19 % was very similar to those
reported by Irwin and colleagues16 and others17 in a similar patient
population, and was slightly higher than that reported by O'Connell
and coworkers13 and McGarvey and associates18 in patients referred
to a tertiary referral center. Thus, it was confirmed that rhinitis
and bronchitis are common causes of chronic cough in this clinical
setting. The modified protocol recognized bronchitis in 41.17% of
patients. The occurrence of chronic cough due to gastroesophageal
reflux as seen in this study is now well established, and mechanisms
have been described by other authors19.
The data suggest that
assessment of airway inflammation is an important addition to the
algorithm for investigating chronic cough. The airway inflammation
was assessed with induced sputum, since this method is noninvasive
and has been shown to be successful in the majority of patients
with asthma20. Sputum differential cell counts have been shown to
be valid and repeatable in patients with asthma21. Sputum induction
is also successful in most patients with chronic cough, and that
sputum eosinophilia is the only significant finding in 13% of cases
of such cough. Although induced sputum was analyzed, spontaneous
sputum could be used if patients have a productive cough. Differential
cell counts are similar with the two methods, but the cell viability
is greater and squamous cell contamination less with induced sputum,
resulting in better quality cytospin preparations22.
The association between
psychological symptoms and cough is interesting in this study. The validity
of the relationship is supported by an epidemiological association between
chronic cough and anxiety, and multiple case reports of psychogenic cough in
the pediatric and adult literature23,24. It is unclear, however, whether
psychological distress is a cause or an effect of chronic cough. Persistent
cough could contribute to excessive psychological distress because of its
ability to disturb sleep, normal work and social activities. Further studies
are needed to clarify these issues.
Diakof Linctus contains many
herbs, which include Vitis vinifera, Ocimum sanctum, Tinospora cordifolia,
Adhatoda vasica, Glycyrrhiza glabra, Balsamodendron mukul and others. The
combined action of all these herbs provide anti-inflamatory and non sedating
antihistaminic property to the linctus. Since diabetic patients with a long
persistent cough have low immune status, herbs such as Tinospora cordifolia
provide immune boosting properties.
The patients in the study
presented with cough without wheezing, dyspnea, or objective evidence of
variable airflow obstruction, and thus did not meet conventional criteria
for the diagnosis of asthma. There was subjective improvement in the cough
and a significant decrease in their sputum eosinophil count after treatment
with Diakof. The improvement began within a week after the treatment begun.
In this study it was evident
that diabetic patients can safely use Diakof Linctus for managing symptoms
of cough. The blood sugar level remained constant throughout the study period.
No untoward side effects were seen in any of the patients.
-
Irwin, R.S., Curley, F.J. and French, C.L. (1990). Chronic
cough: The spectrum and frequency of causes, key components
of the diagnostic evaluation, and outcome of specific therapy.
Am. Rev. Resp. Dis., 141, 640-647.
-
Poe, R.H., Harder, R.V., Israel, R.H. and Kallay, M.C. (1989).
Chronic persistent cough: experience in diagnosis and outcome
using an anatomic diagnostic protocol. Chest, 95, 723-728.
-
Pratter, M.R., Bartter, T., Akers, S. and DuBois, J. (1993).
An algorithmic approach to chronic cough. Ann. Intern. Med.,
119, 977-983.
-
Corrao, W.M. (1996). Chronic persistent cough: diagnosis and
treatment update. Pediatr. Ann., 25, 162-168.
-
Bucca, C., Rolla, G., Scappaticci, E., Baldi, S., Caria, E.
and Oliva, A. (1991). Histamine hyperresponsiveness of the extrathoracic
airway in patients with asthmatic symptoms. Allergy, 46, 147-153.
-
Bucca, C., Rolla, G., Brussino, L., De Rose, L. and Bugiani,
M. (1995). Are asthma-like symptoms due to bronchial or extrathoracic
airway dysfunction? Lancet 346, 791-795.
-
Choudry, N.B., Fuller, R.W. and Pride, N.B. (1989). Sensitivity
of the human cough reflex: effect of inflammatory mediators
prostaglandin E2, bradykinin, and histamine. Am. Rev. Respir.
Dis., 140, 137-141.
-
Bucca, C., Rolla, G., Scappaticci, E. et al. (1990). Hyperresponsiveness
of the extrathoracic airway in patients with captopril-induced
cough. Chest, 98, 1133-1137.
-
Bucca, C., Rolla, G., Scappaticci, E., Chiampo, F., Bugiani,
M., Magnano, M. and D'Alberto, M. (1995). Extrathoracic and
intrathoracic airway responsiveness in sinusitis. J. Allergy
Clin. Immunol., 95, 52-59.
-
Pin, I., Gibson, P.G., Kolendowicz, R. et al. (1992). Use of
induced sputum cell counts to investigate airway inflammation
in asthma. Thorax, 47, 525-529.
-
Gibson, P.G., Dolovich, J., Denburg, J.A., Ramsdale, E.H. and
Hargreave, F.E. (1989). Chronic cough: eosinophilic bronchitis
without asthma. Lancet, i, 1346-1348.
-
Kambic, V. and Radsel, Z. (1994). Acid posterior laryngitis:
aetiology, histology, diagnosis, and treatment. J. Laryngol.
Otol., 98, 1237-1240.
-
O'Connell, F., Thomas, V.E., Pride, N.B. and Fuller, R.W. (1994).
Capsaicin cough sensitivity decreases with successful treatment
of chronic cough. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., 150, 374-380.
-
Ryan, W.J. (1982). Processing of endogenous polypeptides by
the lungs. Ann. Rev. Physiol., 44, 241-255.
-
Irwin, R.S., Corrao, W.M. and Pratter, M.R. (1981). Chronic
persistent cough in the adult: the spectrum and frequency of
causes and successful outcome of specific therapy. Am. Rev.
Respir. Dis., 123, 413-417.
-
Irwin, R.S., Curley, F.J. and French, C.L. (1990). Chronic
cough: the spectrum and frequency of causes, key components
of the diagnostic evaluation, and outcome of specific therapy.
Am. Rev. Respir. Dis., 141, 640-647.
-
Poe, R.H., Harder, R.V., Israel, R.H. and Kallay, M.C. (1989).
Chronic persistent cough: experience in diagnosis and outcome
using an anatomic diagnostic protocol. Chest, 95, 723-728.
-
McGarvey, L.P., Heaney, L.G., Lawson, J.T., Johnston, B.T.,
Scally, C.M., Ennis, M., Shepherd, D.R. and MacMahon, J. (1998).
Evaluation and outcome of patients with chronic non-productive
cough using a comprehensive diagnostic protocol. Thorax, 53:
738-743 .
-
Ing, A., Ngu, M.C. and Breslin, A.B.X. (1994). Pathogenesis
of chronic cough associated with gastroesophageal reflux. Am.
J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., 149, 160-167.
-
Hunter, C.J., Ward, R., Woltmann, G., Wardlaw, A.J. and Pavord,
I.D. (1999). The safety and success rate of sputum induction
using a low output ultrasonic nebuliser. Respir. Med., 93, 345-348.
-
Pizzichini, E., Pizzichini, M.M.M., Efthimiadis, A., Evans,
S., Morris, M.M., Squillace, D., Gleich, G.J., Dolovich, J.
and Hargreave, F.E. (1996). Indices of airway inflammation in
induced sputum: reproducibility and validity of cell and fluid
phase measurements. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., 154, 308-317.
-
Pizzichini, M.M., Popov, T.A., Efthimiadis, A., Hussack, P.,
Evans, S., Pizzichini, E., Dolovich, J. and Hargreave, F.E.
(1996). Spontaneous and induced sputum to measure indices of
airway inflammation in asthma. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med.,
154, 866-869.
Riegel, B., Warmoth, J.E., Middaugh, S.J., Kee, W.G., Nicholson,
L.C., Melton, D.M., Parikh, D.K. and Rosenberg, J.C. (1995). Psychogenic
cough treated with bio?feedback and psychotherapy: a review and
case report. Am. J. Phys. Med. Rehabil., 74, 155-158.
-
Blager, F.B., Gay, M.L. and Wood, R.P. (1988). Voice therapy
techniques adapted to treatment of habit cough: a pilot study.
J. Commun. Disord., 21: 393-400.
|
 |