Urinary Tract
Infections are quite common in day to day practice. The most common
organism generally isolated after urine culture id E. coli. Many a
times E. coli is resistant to the usual line of treatment with urinary
antiseptics and anti-bacterial agents.
Cystone is claimed to be effective in expelling a urinary calculus.
In several recent clinical studies, its value is also claimed in urinary
tract infection to E. coli in non-specific cystitis and persistent
burning micturition syndrome.
The object of the present clinical study is to determine the efficacy
of Cystone tablet in urinary tract infection due to E. coli.
Each tablet of Cystone contains:
Exts. Didymocarpus
pedicellata 65mg
Saxifraga ligulata
49mg
Rubia cordifolia 15
mg
Cyperus scariosus 16
mg
Achyranthes aspera
16mg
Onosma bracteatum 16
mg
Vernonia cinerea 16
mg
Shilajeet (Purified)
13mg
Hajrul yahood bhasma
16mg
Hajrul yahood bhasma
is prepared with Oconum basilicum, Tribulus terrestris, Mimosa pudica,
Dolichos biflorus, Pavonia odorata, Equisetum arvense, Tectona grandis
seed.
Cystone, a drug of vegetable-mineral origin has
been effective in the conservative management of urinary calculi.
The principal pharmacological action of Cystone is as follows:
Cystone disintegrates urinary calculi by acting
on the mucin, which binds the particles together, and clears the
urinary tract by flushing out the particles with the flow of urine.
It also corrects the crystalloid-colloid with the flow of urine.
It also corrects crystalloid-colloid balance (Vakil7,
Sharma5, Agrawal1). Cystone acts as a urinary
antiseptic. It does not alter the electrolyte balance (Subramaniam6).
In urinary tract infections, in cystitis and in
non-specific persistent burning micturition syndrome, Cystone is
effective in eliminating the symptoms and to make the urine sterile
and has no toxic effect on the kidney (Gupta and Singh3,
Sengupta and Subrato Gutpa4 and Brijkishore2).
The present study was
conducted at Darbhanga Medical College and Hospital during the period
1977 to 1979. Twenty five established cases of urinary tract infection
having E. coli in urine culture were selected for the present study.
All patients were subject to a thorough case history and clinical
examination. In each case the routine blood, urine examination,
microscopic urine examination and culture and sensitivity studies
of mid-stream samples were done before administration of Cystone
therapy.
These patients were given
Cystone in the dose of 3 tablets three times a day.
In all these cases,
investigations were repeated during Cystone therapy and clinically
the patients were observed daily and their progress noted.
|
Table
1: Showing the number of cases of U.T.I. with symptoms and
investigatory findings before Cystone therapy
|
|
No.
of cases
|
Symptoms
|
Pus
cells count in urine per high power filed
|
Albuminuria
|
Urine
culture
|
|
25
|
Fever
with rigor, dysuria strangury increased frequency of micturition,
tenderness over the supra-public region and toxic look |
15-90
|
0
- +
|
E.
coli isolated
|
There was definite
improvement in 13 cases. In these cases there was marked improvement
in symptomatology, the pus cell count came to 10-20/h.p.f.; albuminuria
became nil and the urine culture became sterile. These cases were
put in to "Marked improvement" group.
In 7 cases there was
moderate improvement in symptoms; the pus cells came down to 10-40/h.p.f.,
albuminuria persisted and culture remained positive. These cases
were put into "Moderate improvement" group (Table 2).
In 5 cases there was
no improvement at all and these cases were put in "No improvement"
group (Table 2).
|
Table
2: Showing the results of U.T.I. after the end of one week
of Cystone therapy
|
| |
No.
of cases
|
Symptoms
|
Pus
cells count/h.p.f.
|
Albuminuria
|
Urine
culture
|
|
Improvement
|
13
|
Marked
improvement in symptomatology |
10-20
|
Nil
|
Negative
|
|
Moderate
improvement
|
7
|
Moderate
symptoms persisting |
10-40
|
0-
+
|
Positive
E. coli
|
|
No
improvement
|
5
|
No
improvement at all |
15-60
|
+
|
Positive
E. coli
|
In all these cases,
the treatment continued for another week, and at the end of second
week, the urine culture became negative in 18 cases. The number
of pus cell count came down to 2-8/h.p.f. and they were free from
symptoms.
The 18 cases which
responded to Cystone therapy after the 2nd week were
discharged with the advice to continue the treatment with Cystone
for another two weeks at the dose of 2 tablets t.i.d.
These cases turned
up in O.P.D. after two weeks and there was no relapse; the urine
culture was sterile and the pus cell count was almost normal in
all cases.
In 4 cases, there was
moderate improvement in symptoms. The pus cells came to 5-20/h.p.f.
but the culture remained positive (Table 3).
|
Table
3: Showing the results in U.T.I. after second week of Cystone
therapy
|
| |
No.
of cases
|
Symptoms
|
Pus
cells count/h.p.f.
|
Albuminuria
|
Urine
culture
|
|
Marked
improvement
|
18
|
Symptom
free |
2-8
|
Nil
|
Negative
|
|
Moderate
improvement
|
4
|
Moderate
symptoms persisting |
5-20
|
0
- +
|
Positive
|
|
No
improvement
|
3
|
Slight
improvement in symptoms |
15-40
|
+
|
Positive
|
In 3 cases there was
definite fall in pus cell count and also a slight improvement in
symptoms, but albuminuria was present in urine and also the culture
remained positive (Table 3).
In cases with moderate
improvement (Table 3) the treatment was continued into the third
week. At the end of the 3rd week, the urine culture was
still positive, but the pus cell count came to 5-10/h.p.f. and there
was marked improvement in symptomatology. These 4 patients were
treated with a suitable antibiotic along with Cystone and at the
end of 4th week the urine culture in all these cases
became negative. The pus cell count came down in all these 3 cases
to 5-20/h.p.f. and the albumin also decreased. In these 3 patients,
the same treatment was given for a further one week and at the end
of 4th week the culture became negative in the remaining
2 cases also. The pus cell count came down to 2-5/h.p.f.
The role of Cystone
in urinary tract infection due to E. coli seems to be effective
in this clinical trial, though the number of cases treated is small.
- Twenty five cases of U.T.I. due
to E. coli were treated with Cystone in the dose of 3 tablets
three times daily.
- Thirteen cases became culture-negative
in one weeks therapy
- Five more cases became culture-negative
in second weeks therapy.
- The remaining 7 cases did not become
culture-negative even after the end of 3rd week therapy.
However, on the addition of suitable antibiotics, all the 7 culture-positive
cases became negative in 4th week.
- On Cystone therapy, marked improvement
in symptoms was noticed in 1-2 weeks in 18 cases. In 7 cases moderate
to mild improvement in symptoms was noticed.
- Pus cell count decreased gradually
in all cases.
- Albuminuria also decreased gradually.
I am extremely indebted,
to Prof. Mohan Mishra, M.B.,B.S., M.D. M.R.C.P. (U.K.), Professor
in the Department of Medicine, Darbhanga Medical College for his
inspiration, valuable suggestions and guidance without which this
work would not have been possible.
I must express my gratefulness
to Dr. G.P. Keshari, M.B.,B.S., D.L.O. (Lond.), Superintendent
Darbhanga Medical College and Hospital for kindly allowing me to
undertake the trial and to make use of the hospital facilities and
publish this report.
My thanks to The Himalaya
Drug Company for kindly supplying me Cystone tablets for trial.
- Agrawal, S.U. (1960): Capsule, 1: 23.
- Brij. Kishore and Agrawal, G.C. (1979): Capsule, 3: 55.
- Gupta, P.D. and Singh, L.M. (1976): Probe, 2: 108.
- Sengupta, B.R. and Subrato Gupta (1978): Probe, 3: 239.
- Sharma, A.K. (1970): Probe, 4: 179.
- Subramaniam, R. (1961): The Antiseptic, 2: 103.
- Vakil, J.N. (1955): Ind. Practit., 8: 817.
|