| |
The
administration of four tablets of Abana enhanced fibrinolytic activity
in patients of acute myocardial infarction (Group I=10) and healthy
individuals (Group II=10). However, the effect was statistically
not significant. Long-term administration of Abana resulted in statistically
significant (p<0.01) increase in fibrinolytic activity (FA) and
decrease in platelet aggregation (PAg) in healthy adults but not
in coronary artery disease (CAD) patients. In view of its beneficial
effect on fibrinolysis and platelet aggregation, without any untoward
effects, Abana may prove to be a useful adjunct in the long-term
management of individuals predisposed to coronary artery disease.
Abana is a remedy which
contains many herbal compounds1 commonly used by traditional
medical practitioners in the management of cardiovascular disorders.
The hypolipidaemic2, antiatherosclerotic3
and blood pressure lowering effects4,5 have been reported
earlier. It has also been published that Abana has a beneficial
effect in patients of CAD6. Further, it has been found
that the herbal compound drug has effects similar to propranolol
through a different action, i.e. beta-receptor down-regulation7.
The present study has been conducted to evaluate its effect fibrinolytic
activity (FA) and platelet aggregation (PAg) in healthy individuals
and patients of coronary artery disease (CAD).
The
effect of Abana was evaluated after its acute and long-term administration
in healthy individuals and patients of CAD.
1.
Acute effects: The study was conducted on 10 healthy individuals
(mean age 42 years) and 10 patients (mean age 50 years) of acute
myocardial infarction (less than 7 days old). All were non-smokers
and of average build.
Abana
was administered in a single dose of 4 tablets to each subject.
The blood samples were collected in the morning in a fasting condition
and four hours after the drug administration.
2.
Long-term effects: Ten healthy individuals (mean age 42 years)
and 10 patients (mean age 55 years) of CAD were selected for the
study of long-term (3 months) administration of Abana. Patients
having a history of myocardial infarction were included. All the
cases were stabilised and had no recent history of severe angina
or infarction. The last episode of infarction occurred more than
6 months back. All were males, non-smokers. None of them was given
any therapy except isosorbide dinitrate or diazepam. All were ambulatory
and were instructed to make no significant alteration in their normal
dietary or walking schedules throughout the study period. They were
administered Abana or placebo in the following manner:
First
two weeks - Placebo 2 x 2
Third
to sixth week - Abana 2 x 2
Seventh
to tenth week - Abana 2 x 2 x 2
Last
two weeks - Placebo 2 x 2 x 2
The
blood samples were collected initially and after the second, sixth,
tenth and twelfth weeks. All samples were collected in the morning
in a fasting condition about 12 hours after the last dose of the
drug. Care was taken not to apply any undue pressure or tourniquet
on the veins.
Samples
were analysed for fibrinolytic activity (FA)5 and platelet
aggregation (PAg)6.
The
short-term administration of 4 tablets of Abana enhanced FA in healthy
individuals. However, the effect was statistically insignificant
(Table 1). No effect was observed on PAg in both the groups.
|
Table
1: Acute effect of a single dose (4 tablets) of Abana on fibrinolytic
activity (FA) and platelet aggregation (PAg): Mean ± SE
|
| |
Healthy
subjects
|
Acute
M.I. patients
|
|
F.A.
(Units)
|
PAg
(%)
|
F.A.
(Units)
|
PAg
(%)
|
|
Initial
|
71.00
± 4.31
|
84.00
± 2.09
|
53.48
± 5.81
|
88.20
± 2.41
|
|
After
4 hours
|
78.44
± 4.56
|
80.40
± 1.85
|
58.92
± 6.12
|
87.40
± 2.77
|
|
p
value
|
NS
|
NS
|
NS
|
NS
|
On long-term administration of Abana, FA was significantly (p<0.01)
enhanced in healthy individuals and PAg was also reduced significantly.
In patients of CAD, Abana also increased FA and decreased PAg, but
the effect was statistically not significant (Table 2).
|
Table 2: Effect
of long-term administration of Abana on fibrinolytic activity
(FA) and platelet aggregation (PAg) in healthy individuals
and in patients of CAD
|
| |
Initial
|
2nd
week
|
6th
week
|
10th
week
|
12th
week
|
|
Healthy
Adults
|
| FA
(Units) |
63.25
± 3.81
|
66.22
± 2.93
|
69.28
± 2.93
|
71.32
± 3.53
|
68.42
± 3.40
|
| p
value |
|
NS
|
<0.01
|
<0.01
|
NS
|
|
CAD Patients
|
| FA
(Units) |
56.06
± 3.52
|
57.28
± 3.74
|
63.80
± 3.20
|
63.71
± 3.31
|
57.74
± 2.54
|
| p
value |
|
NS
|
NS
|
NS
|
NS
|
| PAg
(%) |
84.20
± 2.34
|
83.20
± 2.30
|
79.70
± 1.51
|
79.20
± 1.43
|
80.90
± 1.67
|
| p
value |
|
NS
|
NS
|
NS
|
NS
|
In
the recent past, several attempts have been made to evaluate the
clinical significance of many herbal preparations, especially in
the prevention and management of CAD. Abana has also been evaluated
for its effect on blood lipids2, blood pressure4,
heart rate10 and symptoms of neurocirculatory disorders11.
The present study further adds to its multifold action.
In
the acute experiments, Abana was found to be ineffective both in
healthy adults and in patients of CAD. However, during long-term
study, beneficial effects of FA and PAg were observed at the end
of the first month of drug administration. The significant effect
was observed in healthy adults only, although a slight increase
in FA and decrease in PAg were also seen in patients of CAD (P=NS).
The delayed effect of Abana may be explained on the basis that the
drug may be taking some weeks to build up its effect, which may
be commonly seen in the case of most herbal drugs. It was surprising
to note that Abana was only effective in healthy adults while no
significant effect was seen in Cad patients. This may be explained
on the basis that in CAD patients there may be multiple factors
influencing the blood coagulability and there would be abnormalities
of lipid levels. These may not be directly influenced by Abana in
a short period and may require further prolonged administration.
Secondly, perhaps a larger dose of the drug may be required in these
patients of CAD for producing significant effects.
The
significance of fibrinolysis and PAg has been stressed from time
to time12. Gupta et al.13 studied the fibrinolytic
activity and platelet adhesiveness in 150 patients of IHD. They
observed increased platelet adhesiveness and decreased FA in patients
of IHD significantly. It is also documented that in 90 per cent
of acute myocardial infarction there is thrombus formation. The
thrombus formation was documented on the basis of coronary angiography
performed during the evolving period of myocardial infarction14.
In view of these findings, Abana may be useful in the management
of patients predisposed to CAD, particularly in the light of its
beneficial effect on FA and PAg.
-
Editors note: Composition of Abana. Probe
(1985): 25, 1.
-
Dubey, G.P., Agarwal, A., Srivastava, V.K.,
Agarwal, U. and Udupa, K.N., Management of risk factors of coronary
heart disease with an indigenous compound Abana. Probe
(1985): 1, 46.
-
Panda, B.K., Nanda, S.K., Praharaj, N.K. and
Dwevedi, S.K., Effect of Abana in experimentally induced hypercholesterolaemia
in chicken. Probe (1987): 27, 92.
-
Gore, A.G., The management of hypertension
with Abana. Probe (1985): 1, 64.
-
Salkar, R.G., Salkar, H.R. and Deshmukh, P.Y.,
Role of Abana in hypertension. The Antiseptic (1987):
12, 719.
-
Dubey, G.P., Agarwal, A. and Udupa, K.N., Prevention
and management of CHD by an indigenous compound Abana. Alternative
Medicine (1986): 3, 241.
-
Thatte, M.S., Doshi, B.S. and Kulkarni, R.D.,
Effect of Abana on beta-receptors. Ind. Drugs (1986):
23, 11.
-
Biggs, R. and Macfarlane, R.G.: Technical methods,
In: Human blood coagulation and disorderes. Appendix 3, Blackwell,
Oxford 91962), p. 395.
-
Harms, C.S. and Triplett, D.A.: Platelet aggregation
laboratory management, ASCP Press, Chicago (1977), p. 34.
-
Singh, N., Singh, S.P., Pant, K.K., Dixit,
K.S. and Kohli, R.P., Some cardiovascular effects of Abana,
an Ayurvedic herbal drug combination. Probe (1985): 1,
17.
-
Basu, D.P. and Joshi, R.L., Abana in cardiac
neurosis and similar conditions. Probe (1986): 2, 131.
-
Sassa, H., Ito, T., Niwa, t. and Matsui, E.,
Fibrinolysis in patients with ischaemic heart disease. Jap.
Circulat. J. 91975): 525, 39.
-
Gupta, K.K. et al., Cholesterol, platelet
adhesiveness and fibrinolytic activity in IHD. J. Asso. Phy.
India (1969): 17, 323.
-
Dewod, M.A., Spores, J., Notske, R., Mouser,
L.T., Burroughs, R., golden, M.S. and lang, H.T., Prevalence
of total coronary occlusion during the early hours of transmural
M.I. N. Engl. J. Med. (1980): 303, 897.
|
 |